Where does the search For ethnic indicators lead

Where does the search For ethnic indicators lead

№ 1(31)2021

Страницы:

136 –

140 Язык: английский

Открыть файл статьи

Аннотация

This is a critical review of the article by Allanazar Sopiev “Traditional Technologies and Artistic Techniques for Finishing Weapons in the Collection of the State Museum of Turkmenistan” published in the Bulletin of IICAS, Issue 29. This peer-reviewed work touches on topical, yet poorly studied, issues concerning decorative techniques on weapons in Central Asia, which were previously raised by researchers more than thirty years ago. The manufactured weapons as presented by Sopiyev which he ascribes to the Turkmen are disputed, and in certain cases, he provides no references to trustworthy sources or archival documents. It also addresses other controversial issues pertaining to the use of weapons by the Turkmen, as well as the particulars surrounding their decoration.

Список использованных источников

Baskakov, N. A., Karryev, B. A., and Khamzayev, M. Ya.(ed.). (1968) Turkmensko-russkiy slovar [Turkmen-Russian Dictionary]. M., Sovetskaya entsiklopediya Publ. (In Russian).

Botyakov, Yu. M., Yanborisov, V. R. (1989). Kholodnoye oruzhie turkmen [Bladed weapons of the Turkmen],Pamyatniki traditsionno-bytovoy kultury narodov Sredney Azii, Kazahstana i Kavkaza (Sbornik Muzeya antropologii i etnografii. Vyp. 43) [Monuments of the Traditional Everyday Culture of the Peoples of Central Asia, Kazakhstan and the Caucasus, issue 43]. Leningrad:Nauka Publ., p. 49-60 (in Russian).

Johnson, Fr. (1852). A Dictionary, Persian, Arabic and English. London.

Karryev, B. A. (1983). Gyor-ogly. Turkmenskiy geroicheskiy epos [Gyor-ogly: Turkmen Heroic Epic]. Moscow:Nauka Publ. (In Russian).

Kirpichnikov, N. A. (1897). Kratkiy ocherk nekotoryh tuzemnyh promyslov v Samarkandskoy oblasti [A Brief Outline of Some Indigenous Crafts in the Samarkand Region], Spravochnaya knizhka Samarkandskoy oblasti. 1897 [Reference Book of the Samarkand Region 1897]. Issue V, Samarkand (in Russian).

Lansdell, H. (1885). Russian Central Asia, including Kuldja, Bokhara, Khiva and Merv. Vol. II. London.

Lyutov, A. M. (2006). Kholodnoe oruzhie v sobranii Rossiyskogo etnograficheskogo muzeya [The Bladed Weapons in the Collection of the Russian Ethnographic Museum].St.Petersbirg: Mak Publ. (In Russian).

Meyendorff, G. W. (1826). Voyage d’Orenbourg à Boukhara fait en 1820, à travers les steppes qui s`etendent a l`est de la mer d`aral et au-dela de l`ancien jaxartes, Paris.

Richardson, J. (1829). Dictionary, Persian, Arabic, and English: With a Dissertation on the Languages, Literature and Manners of Eastern Nations. London.

Semyonov, O. S. (2010). Avtorskoye oruzhie. Sozdanie obraza, otdelka [Copyright Author’s Weapon. Image Creation, Decoration]. M., Adelant Publ. (In Russian).

Sopiyev, A. O. (2020). Traditional Technologies and Artistic Techniques for Finishing Weapons Presented in the Collection of the State Museum of Turkmenistan, Bulletin of IICAS. Issue 29, pp. 65-86.

Voennyy sbornik (1872). Turkmeny yomudskogo plemeni [Turkmen of the Yomud Tribe], Voennyy sbornik [Military collection]. No 1. St.Peyersburg (in Russian).Voennyy sbornik (1888). Ocherk ekspeditsiy v Ahal-Teke v 1879-1880 gg. [A Summary of the Expeditions in Akhal-Tek in 1879-1880], Voennyy sbornik [Military collection]. No 5. St.Petresburg (in Russian).