Historiography of relations between the ottoman empire and the states of central asia In the 16th–19th centuries

  • № 34 2022

Страницы: 

119

 – 

125

Язык: английский

Открыть файл статьи
Открыть страницу статьи в Интернет

Аннотация

This article provides a reflection on the political and diplomatic relations between the Ottoman Empire and the states of Central Asia during the 16th–19th centuries in Western European, Soviet, and Russian historiography.The various methods among scholars from different countries of studying this topic is highlighted. It is noted that the politicization of the subject pertaining to relations between the Porte and the Central Asian khanates affected the views of researchers. Most of them studied Bukhara-Persian, Bukhara-Indian relations in the period of Baburids, Bukhara-Russian, Ottoman-Persian, and Ottoman-Russian relations from the perspective of the great power rivalry for influence in the Central Asian region. The article draws attention to certain differences in historical research by European, Soviet, and Russian historians. It emphasizes the difference in their foundation source material, which influenced their scholarly approaches. The analysis discusses the works reflecting on the influence of the Sublime Porte on Central Asia and the contacts between the Uzbek khans and the Turkish sultans, the problems arising for Islamic pilgrims from Turkistan, and the issues of military and political alliances of the Uzbek khanates with the Ottoman Empire. The historical works are reviewed in chronological order concerning the development of relations between the Ottoman Empire and Central Asia during this period.

Список использованных источников

  1. Allouche, A. (1983). The Origins and Development of the Ottoman-Safavid Conflict. (906−962/1500−1555). Berlin:Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1983.
  2. Bacqué-Grammont, J. L. (1970). Une liste ottomane de princes et d‘apanages Abu‘l-Khayrides. In: Cahiers du monde russe et soviétique, vol. 11, n°3, Juillet-septembre1970.pp. 423−453. URL: persee.fr/doc/cmr_0008-0160_1970_num_11_3_1817.
  3. Bacqué-Grammont, J. L. (1992). Ubaydu-lláh Han de Boukhara et Soliman le Magnifique. Sur quelques pièces de correspondance. Études turco-safavides,XVII», Soliman le Magnifique et son temps. Actes du Colloque de Paris, Galeries Nationalesdu Grand Palais, 7−10 mars 1990, éd. Gilles Veinstein, École du Louvre,École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Paris, La Documentation Française, , Pp. 485-504.
  4. Bennigsen, A. (2009). Tureckij pohod na Astrahan’ v 1569 g. po materialam «Reestrov vazhnyh del» Osmanskogo arhiva // Vostochnaja Evropa Srednevekov’ja i rannego Novogo vremeni glazami francuzskih istorikov. [“The Turkish Campaign to Astrakhan in 1569 according to the ‘Registers of Important Cases’ in the Ottoman Archive”// Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Age through the Eyes of French Historians.]Kazan, Pp. 145-166 (in Russian).
  5. Bennigsen, A., Berindey M. (2009). Astrahan’ i politika v stepjah Severnogo Prichernomor’ja (1587−1588 gg.) //Vostochnaja Evropa Srednevekov’ja i rannego Novogo vremeni glazami francuzskih istorikov. [“Astrakhan and Politics in the Steppes of the Northern Black Sea Region (1587-1588)” // Eastern Europe of the Middle Ages and Early Modernity through the Eyes of French Historians.] Kazan, Pp. 194-213 (in Russian).
  6. Bennigsen A., Lemercier-Kielkeje C. (2009). Bol’shaja Nogajskaja Orda i problema kontaktov mezhdu Osmanskoj imperiej i Central’noj Aziej v 1552−1556 gg.// Vostochnaja Evropa Srednevekov’ja i rannego Novogo vremeni glazami francuzskih istorikov. [“The Great Nogai Horde and the problem of contacts between the Ottoman Empire and Central Asia in 1552-1556.” //Eastern Europe of the Middle Ages and Early Modern Age through the Eyes of French Historians] Kazan, Pp. 86-115 (in Russian).
  7. Bosworth, С. E. (1967). The Islamic Dynasties. A Chronological and Genealogical Handbook. Edinburgh: University Ptress, 1.
  8. Boulger, D. C. (1878). The Life of Yakoob-Beg: Athalik Ghazi and Badaulet. London: W. H. Allen & co.Burton, A. (1997). The Bukharans: A Dynastic, Diplomatic and Commercial History. 1550−1702. Richmond: CurzonPress.Burton, A. (1990-91). “Relations between the Khanate of Bukhara and Ottoman Turkey, 1558−1702.” // IJTS. V-5, № 1-2, University of Wisconsin. Pp. 83−103.Carrère d’Encausse, E. (2009). Torgovye puti Central’noj Azii i popytki otvoevanija Astrahani // Vostochnaja Evropa Srednevekov’ja i rannego Novogo vremeni glazami francuzskih istorikov. “Trade Routes of Central Asia and the Attempts to Recapture Astrakhan” // The Eastern Europe of the Middle Ages and Early Modern Age through the Eyes of French Historians. Kazan, Pp.116-144 (in Russian).
  9. Chikhachev, P. A. (1970). Velikie derzhavy i Vostochnyj vopros. [The Great Powers and the Eastern Question].Moscow: Nauka, (in Russian).
  10. Fadeeva, I.L. (1985). Oficial’nye doktriny v ideologii i politike Osmanskoj imperii (Osmanizm-panislamizm) [Official Doctrines in Ideology and Politics of the Ottoman Empire (Ottomanism-Pan-Islamism)]. Moscow:Nauka, (in Russian).
  11. Hammer-Purgstall, J. (1827-1835). Geschichte des osmanischen Reiches grossenteil aus bisher unbenutzten Handshiften und Archivendurch Joseph von Hammer.Pesth: 1827−1835. Bd. 3.
  12. Ivanov, P.P. (1958). Ocherki po istorii Srednej Azii. [Essays on the History of Central Asia] Moscow:Oriental Literature Publisher, (in Russian).
  13. Khalfin, N.A. (1965). Prisoedinenie Srednej Azii k Rossii.[The Accession of Central Asia to Russia]. Moscow:Nauka (in Russian). Khalfin, N.A. (1957). Sultanskaja Turcija i anglijskaja jekspansija v Srednej Azii (50−80 gg XIX v.) [“Sultan’s Turkiye and English Expansion in Central Asia(1850−1880)”] // Proceedings of the University of Central Asia. A new series. Issue 94. Vol. 14 Tashkent, Pp. 29-45 (in Russian).
  14. Kuropatkin, A. N. (1879). Kashgarija. Istoriko-geograficheskij ocherk strany, ejo voennye sily, promyshlennost’ i torgovlja. Kashgaria. A Historical and Geographical Sketch of the Country, Its Military Forces, Industry and Trade. St. Petersburg: Imperial Russian Geographical Society, (in Russian).
  15. Litvinov, V. P. (2016). «Svjatye mesta» musul’man Turkestana kak centry antirossijskoj dejatel’nosti tureckoj agentury (vtoraja polovina XIX–nachalo XX v.) [“Sacred Places” of Turkestan Muslims as Centers of anti-Russian Activities of the Turkish Agency (Second half of the 19th - early 20th Centuries) // Bulletin of Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia, No. 2, History of Russia Series, Pp. 55-65 (in Russian).
  16. Smirnov, N. A. (1946). Rossija i Turcija v XVI−XVII vv.[Russia and Turkiye in the 16th-17th Centuries] Vol. I. Moscow: Moscow State University Press, (in Russian).Trepavlov, V. V. (2002). Istorija Nogajskoj Ordy. [History of the Nogay Horde]. Moscow: Eastern Literature, (in Russian).
  17. Trepavlov, V. V. (2009). Tjurkskie narody Evrazii i Osmanskaja imperija v XVI v. // Vostochnaja Evropa Srednevekov’ja i rannego Novogo vremeni glazami francuzskih istorikov [“The Turkic Peoples of Eurasia and the Ottoman Empire in the 16th Century” // Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Age through the Eyes of French Historians.] Kazan, 2009.Pp. 7-34 (in Russian).
  18. Vamberi, A. (1873). Istorija Bohary ili Transoksianii s drevnejshih vremen do nastojashhego. [History of Bohara or Transoxiana from Ancient Times to the Present].Vol. II. St. Petersburg, (Russian edition).
  19. Vasiliev, A. D. (2014). «Znamja i Mech ot Padishaha». Politicheskie i kul’turnye kontakty hanstv Central’noj Azii i Osmanskoj imperii (seredina XVI−nachalo XX vv.).[The Banner and the Sword from the Padishah. Political and Cultural Contacts between the Khanates of Central Asia and the Ottoman Empire (mid-16th-early 20th centuries)] Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies,Russian Academy of Sciences, (in Russian).
  20. Vasiliev, A. D. (2015). “The Ottoman Empire and the ‘Great Game’ in Kashgar (1865-1878)” // Historical Herald.Russia and the Islamic World. Vol. 11 (158). Мoscow,2015. Pp. 224-250.Vasiliev, A. D. (2016). Osmanskij protektorat i rossijskaja politika v Kashgare v 70-h – nachale 80-h gg. HIH vv.// Mir bol’shogo Altaja 2(2.2) [“The Ottoman Protectorate and Russian policy in Kashgar in the 1870s- early 1880s” // The World of the Great Altai 2(2.2).2016. Pp. 373–384 (in Russian).
  21. Zaitsev, I.V. (2006). Kokandec v Stambule (Iz Kokanda «prelestnogo» v «vilajet Islambol». [From Kokand ‘Charming’ to ‘vilayet Islambol’: Two Moscow Manuscripts and the Kokand Mission to Istanbul in 1838-1840)”] // Turkology Collection 2005. Moscow: Oriental Literature, 2006. Pp. 189–194 (in Russian).

Список всех публикаций, цитирующих данную статью